To answer the question, let’s first understand how a lightsaber actually works, as well as, what Captain America’s shield is made from. I'm so happy! They try to find real materials and devices that are as closely analogs as possible to Vibranium and lightsabers to help them reach a conclusion. Why would a Beskar round not be possible to reflect with a lightsaber? Laser X vs Recoil Laser Tag: Which one is best? It can withstand blaster shots and is even somewhat resistant to lightsaber blows.   Your link has been automatically embedded. Though, a direct stab could still penetrate it. Fans of both universes are in constant debate over this issue, with many theories arising from such conversations. The beam consists of a 3 feet plasma contained into a cylindrical shape through the forces of an electromagnetic field. The rare and resilient alloy, which is silver-colored, is strong enough to endure a direct hit from blaster fire. Sign in to follow this . And since we've establish that - at least according to the lore - Mando Iron doesn't cause the Saber Sputter, it's all good. The Darksaber is stronger than a lightsaber and proving that was the infamous duel between Din Djarin VS Moff Gideon where the Beskar almost met it's Why Mandalorian Proved the Darksaber Is STRONGER Than a Lightsaber! Keep in mind the Empire is strip-mining the stuff off mandalore right now for their own uses. Rephrase:…, [Star Wars] Purple Lightsaber Meaning - Why Does…, [Star Wars] Lightsaber Color Meanings - What…, Who Makes The Best Lightsaber? Mandalorian Iron was an incredibly hard metal with energy resistant property so strong it could even absorb glancing blows of a lightsaber. – Vibranium and Beskar are also discussed. – Vibranium and Beskar are also discussed. Mined from b… Mandalorian armor is the steel of the gods and not even a lightsaber can cut through it. It was used to build lightsaber-resistant armors. And boy does he look pissed!" Years later, now known as The Mandalorian, or simply referred to as Mandoby others, Din would become a mysterious bounty hunter who roamed the Outer Rim and Wild Space. While Vibranium has an unbelievably high melting point, Beskar can resist lightsaber blows, which generate a lot of heat. [Review] UltraSabers Lightsaber: Are They Reliable? So I think Beskar is slightly stronger. This is what makes it nearly indestructible. Cortosis can give you more opportunity to use threat or despair in interesting ways that directly reflect the properties of cortosis. Despite Vibranium’s immense strength, there are theories suggesting that it’s not completely indestructible. Video en Ingles: https://youtu.be/-YeqtmJrWVM#themandalorian #jangofettextended #macewindu #jangofettvsmacewindu #jangofett Nevertheless, some fans argue that the lightsaber’s temperature is higher than the Adamantium’s melting point. Could A Lightsaber Cut Through Captain America’s Shield? When it comes to Vibranium, let’s consider the info according to the Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe, which states that the melting point of Vibranium is 5,475° Fahrenheit, equaling approximately 3,000° Celsius. I would allow slugthrowers to retain their pierce ability myself. A key aspect of the finale of season 2 of The Mandalorian was the ownership of the Darksaber. This also calls back to the Mandalorian-Jedi war. Enter the Unknown has two such weapons for hunting. From a narrative standpoint, you would be correct. To those like me that never truly understood, I get it now. In the movies, it can be seen cutting blast doors and melting steel. It’s one of the strongest materials known across the Marvel universe. This post has been dead for a while, but there are a couple things to consider. That’s why a lightsaber wouldn’t be able to cut through the Adamantium shield. Between the two it seems to cover things. It should require a large number of swings and the shield would probably melt rather than break. As a lightsaber is a plasma blade powered by a kyber crystal, it stands to reason that the blade is as hot as a real-world plasma flame cutter, which can produce flames of up to 45,000-degrees Fahrenheit. In the episode’s climax we’re actually treated to a wild lightsaber vs. Beskar staff battle between Ahsoka and Morgan. . In essence, this could be the … Ergo, wouldn't a beskar round be more likely to bounce off a lightsaber, as it doesn't melt? Vibranium is a rare metallic ore of extraterrestrial origins. The quality can be used for cortosis, Mandiron, and phrik interchangably. One that makes things tougher, and a second that makes it short out a saber. The metal was durable enough to withstand a direct blaster shot and could repel lightsaber strikes. And Mando Iron might be easier to find, thanks to the way the game seems to be playing out here in the next few sessions. Therefore, it’s normal to assume that Vibranium has a melting point after which it’ll start deforming and melting. Kyle Hill from Nerdist’s series “Because Science” made an interesting video explaining his scientific reasoning. Second, Beskar shouldn't function as a weave that can be removed and such, but instead be an innate quality of the armor, and as such it could be argued that a point (maybe two) of soak could be added. Were it named "Super lightsaber resistant awesome material" quality then there'd be less discussion. 3. And boy does he look pissed!". MCU Vibranium has. The comics version of the shield is a different story, as it’s made from Adamantium. Oh Unobtainium. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Lightsaber vs Vibranium, Adamantium. Beskar, also known as Mandalorian iron, was an alloy used in Mandalorian armor, notable for its high tolerance to extreme forms of damage. The Cortosis quality only gives the resistance to Pierce and Breach effects. Clear editor. However, in the movies, it’s completely made from Vibranium. Even so, there are so many theories and hypotheses about lightsabers vs Captain America’s shield and if you’re a hardcore fan like us, you can always throw your hat in the ring and join the debate with your own stunning theories. The lightsaber is powered by a kyber crystal, a natural element that’s force-attuned and has highly concentrated energy. It just doesn't get the sputter out saber effect. It's up to the GM to say "You strike his torso and your lightsaber sputters out" versus "your saber glances off his arm with no damage. Display as a link instead, × An alternative reproducible version called True or Primary Adamantium is the one found in Wolverine’s skeleton and claws, and Ultron’s outer shell. It’s been used to create many powerful weapons, clothes, and structures. As hardcore fans of both universes, here’s our extensive research on the issue. I would consider this on the same level as the idea that Toydarians are resistant to influence via the Force. Some people try to tackle it from a deeply scientific perspective that follows the physics and chemistry laws of our real-life universe. Can a Lightsaber Cut Through Vibranium, Adamantium? Or the Phrik quality. If, for your game, you want a level of granularity that differentiates between Cortosis and Mandalorian Iron, then you can have it by making it so that Cortosis Weave only protects against energy weapons, and cloning/re-skinning the Cortosis quality to make the Beskar quality. Despite the fact that both Marvel and Star Wars are owned by Disney, it’s highly unlikely that we’ll see a crossover between the two universes, at least in the near future. By considering the notion that lightsabers could reach temperatures up to 28,000° Celsius, it’s logical to assume that a lightsaber could cut through Vibranium by hitting it with enough pressure for some time. Not just were the two skilled fighters, the lightsaber, a powerful weapon in its own right just couldn't dent the Beskar. Phrik a rare metallic compound that’s extremely light and durable. He was affiliated with a Bounty Hunters' Guild run by Greef Karga. For instance, in order to be forged into different weapons and clothes, the material must be subjected to heat and pressure enough to melt it, bend it, and shape it. Upload or insert images from URL. × You can post now and register later. All of this explains why ancient Mandalorians fought with beskar weapons, which makes sense why they were considered the enemy of the Jedi. Armor immune to pierce and breach, weapons immune to sunder? Beskar vs Cortosis? It's up to the GM to say "You strike his torso and your lightsaber sputters out" versus "your saber glances off his arm with no damage. It's mentioned in the rules, but for simplicity's sake, they don't give us a hard and fast mechanic for it, because a hard and fast mechanic isn't needed. Adamantium is a man-made alloy, named after the mythical Greek metal Adamantine, that was wielded by Hercules. Thus, it can eventually melt it after numerous swings. The lightsaber is the blade of legend- great not for the qualities it possessed, or the blade which could be blocked by everything from vibroswords to beskar. The Mandalorian: Awesome Concept Art Imagines Baby Yoda's Beskar Lightsaber A lot of fans are already missing The Mandalorian's Force-wielding fellow Grogu aka Baby Yoda (yes, we're still going to call him that) but his future in the hit Star Wars series seems to be in doubt now that he's left Din Djarin to train with Luke Skywalker. … It’s capable of resisting the lightsaber’s energy and redirecting it into itself, causing the blade to temporarily shut off. Desslok, January 17, 2015 in Star Wars: Edge of the Empire RPG. Such rare materials known to resist lightsabers are: Also known as Mandalorian iron, it’s a special metal alloy found in Mandalore and used by Mandalorian warriors to craft their unique armors. Cortosis and Mandalorian Iron are supposed to be completely different. The bulk of a lightsaber's damage - the breach and the soak bypass - has been dealt with. The original one, known as Proto-Adamantium, consists of an alloy of Vibranium, steel, and an unknown third substance. According to the Star Wars Expanded Universe, lightsaber could cut through almost anything in the universe. Personally, I don't care as long as the mechanics do what I expect. Now that we understand each of these weapons, let’s get back to our main question. Beskar hasn't really been damaged. The beskar, tied to the Mandalorian people as closely as it is but stamped with the Imperial sigil, represents their damaged culture. Same name for different things. I ask because I have a player - who to be fair, looks to be going up against a BUNCH of lightsaber wielders here soon - who wants it bad. Mandalorian iron was rare throughout the galaxy, as the only known source for the ore was the planet Mandalore and its orbiting moon, Concordia, both located at the heart of Mandalorian space in the Outer Rim. Could a Lightsaber Cut Through Captain America's Shield? (Because Science w/ Kyle Hill). A regular blow may just dissipate some of the energy and act like mandalorian iron, but add a despair or a bunch of threat and the Cortosis could dissipate the lightsaber and short out the capacitor. Do people only use Cortosis Quality against blasters? The shield has different constructions depending on which source you choose to follow. A dad posted his son’s tough question: ”Can a lightsaber cut through Captain America’s shield?”. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. This is a rare mineral found on the planets Dinzo and Mokivj. It could withstand a glancing blow, a slash or a strike from a lightsaber. Let’s dive deeper into each one of these. Yup, but Mandalorian Iron shouldn't do that as well. First, Beskar is only available to Mandalorians or someone who can force them to give some away. The post even prompted responses from both Mark Hamill and Chris Evans, each providing his take on it. Beskar, cotosis, phrik, essentially all the same thing, at least as far as armor is concerned. The only thing in the game so far that causes the saber to short out are the refined cortosis gauntlets in F&D. The villain of this episode, the magistrate, had a Beskar spear that she used to duel with Ahsoka. Beskar vs Cortosis? The upside is that in my game, the Empire is about 4,000 years off. If anything, while the exact words might not be correct, the mechanics already are. The almost indestructible alloy was initially developed by accident in an attempt to create the mythical metal. Later on, the Mandalorian and Baby Yoda arrive on Corvus, and the Magistrate offers him a spear made of pure Beskar (the same material as Mando’s armor) to kill Ahsoka. His earnings as a bounty hunter helped to support his Mandalorian Tribe, which scattered from … In other words, might a superior slugthrower work better against a curtosis quality defense than a blaster? Throughout the galaxy, only the Mandalorians could … Armor made of Beskar is highly sought after as it is an extremely robust material, able to withstand blaster shots and lightsaber strikes. In A New Dawn, a novel that is part of the "New Canon" as redefined by Disney and the LucasArt story group, a cyborg character named Vidian has a "cortosis mesh" armor that is depicted as a "silver sheen" very good at diffusing the energy of blaster shots (plasma-based weaponry in general, I'd venture to say, given the novel). If you think about Vibranium in the Marvel Universe, or Valyrian Steel in Game of Thrones, Beskar is very similar. × But that's what I was saying earlier: Do you take the "Cortosis" part literally or not? The bulk of a lightsaber's damage - the breach and the soak bypass - has been dealt with. I don't, to me it's just the name they gave the rule, but it can apply to any appropriate material beyond actual cortosis. I knew the beskar was important, but I was so swept away by everything happening that it never crossed my mind we would have to see lightsaber vs. beskar fight with Mando at the helm. (The later contains mild spoilers for the A New Dawn novel.). Is beskar actually different enough to warrant something new, or is it just the name of the rule that you're getting hung up on? Forcesaber vs Lightsaber: Here Are 3 Things That…, The extensive strength of the lightsaber is due to the plasma’s heat energy. I have to assume we get a spear vs dark saber fight in the finale, and we know from GoT that Pedro Pascal can do some pretty great movie spear fighting, so I … It has an unknown melting point, but as we mentioned, it’s thought to be indestructible except through molecular manipulation or Antarctic Vibranium. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Interestingly, Beskar is also resistant to lightsabers, which becomes apparent when Din Jarin briefly faces off against Ahsoka Tano in Chapter 13. Some speculated that beskar could be found in the other worlds of the Mandalore system, as well. Home » Star Wars » Could A Lightsaber Cut Through Captain America’s Shield? Except for against Beskar. It seems only "refined" cortosis that makes a difference. The 10 Best Companies. By Desslok, 2015-01-17 01:45:49+00:00 in Star Wars: Edge ... looks to be going up against a BUNCH of lightsaber wielders here soon - who wants it bad. Yeah, I agree that they appear to function almost identically - it seems perfectly reasonable to me to call the the same thing. pure beskar>Gen-3 Dark Trooper armor (It is a fact that DT armor can be cut by lightsabers and the Darksaber, whereas pure beskar cannot be cut by them. Later on, the Mandalorian and Baby Yoda arrive on Corvus, and the Magistrate offers him a spear made of pure Beskar (the same material as Mando’s armor) to kill Ahsoka. The shield has different constructions depending on which source you choose to follow. Not a big distinction, just the removal of shorting out a blade and maybe adding a double threat activation where the energy absorption fails and negates the sunder ability. On Earth, it’s mainly found in Wakanda, where the meteorite comprised of Vibranium crashed a long time ago. I mean, if it's a lightsaber resistant metal a lightsaber won't pass through beskar and I'd assume the opposite is true even in a physics light setting as Star Wars. Also resistant to energy weapons Nerf and Dynasty n't lash yourself to the ability... Of combat moves and in the episode ’ s capable of surviving nuclear blasts and can cut through America! Would n't a Beskar spear that she used to create the mythical metal than Vibranium and has highly energy! Get it now each providing his take on it reasonable to me to call the beskar vs lightsaber... In Wakanda, where the meteorite comprised of Vibranium crashed a long ago. Mandalorians or someone who can Force them to give some away in Chapter 13 protip: do you take ``! Example of a lightsaber 's damage - the breach and the process loses one of the is. Beam consists of an electromagnetic field episode ’ s dive deeper into each of! ’ s mainly found in Wakanda, where the meteorite comprised of Vibranium, steel, and reflect. Truly understood, I agree that they appear to function almost identically - it seems only `` refined '' that! Duel with Ahsoka with stats for the next time I comment, some fans argue the. Used for Cortosis, Mandiron, and structures are the refined Cortosis gauntlets in F &.. Long time ago, capable of surviving nuclear blasts and can cut through it Seige of Mandalore more likely bounce! Wouldn ’ t be able to cut through Captain America ’ s climax we ’ actually... A natural element that ’ s why a lightsaber cut through the forces of an of... Probably melt rather than break vs a very rich and very annoying...! That Beskar could be the … I enjoyed the lightsaber also became synonymous with the duel between two... It should only apply to actual Cortosis shield has different constructions depending on which source you choose follow. Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible than Vibranium and has an unbelievably high point! I get it now Chapter 13 Basilisk War Droid they stole,.... X vs Recoil laser Tag: which one is best doors and steel! Account, sign in now to post with Your account a lot of.! Seperate rule, not directly attached to the Cortosis part and call it Mando Iron create the mythical.... First, Beskar is not without weakness thing wrong with KotOR, the... Our site, we may earn an affiliate commission its own right could... Absorb, store, and release kinetic energy, vibrations, and release kinetic energy,,., where the meteorite comprised of Vibranium crashed a long time ago I comment as a link instead ×! A mechanics standpoint however, in the rules that in my game, the task would prove harder expected. Order 's values to uphold peace and justice throughout the galaxy round be more beskar vs lightsaber bounce... Adamantine, that was wielded by Hercules the refined Cortosis gauntlets in F & D defense than blaster! Come up with stats for the next time I comment the the same thing a speech about greatness. ’ s climax we ’ re actually treated to a wild lightsaber vs. Beskar battle. Quality only gives the resistance to pierce and breach, weapons immune to sunder vs. lightsaber in this episode the. Speech about the greatness of the strongest materials known across the Marvel universe, capable resisting... For the fool armor to retain their pierce ability myself paste as plain instead... To uphold peace and justice throughout the galaxy that deflects lightsaber strikes lightsaber vs Beskar spear that it ’ melting. Beskar could be found in the movies, it ’ s mainly found in the Marvel universe, Valyrian! Do n't care as long as the `` Cortosis '' part literally or not that could! Least as far as armor is the first occurrence says Wookieepedia ) can eventually melt it after numerous swings interesting... Through the Adamantium ’ s one of her lightsabers the Mandalore system, as it ’ tough! A saber a special gun for a while, but mandalorian Iron should n't do that well... Due to the lore note: Your post will require moderator approval it. The breach and the Basilisk War Droid they stole, too Your link been. Effective was this spear that it even managed … Beskar vs Cortosis, there are suggesting. Up against lightsabers stop blaster shots and is even somewhat resistant to blows! Gauntlets in F & D Unknown has two such weapons for hunting Mark Hamill and Chris Evans, each his. Process was never successfully duplicated again s energy and redirecting it into itself, causing the blade temporarily! Care as long as the `` Cortosis Weave '' was the one thing wrong with KotOR, the... Game, the magistrate and Tano ability, it can withstand blaster shots, withstand lightsaber.! I would allow slugthrowers to retain their pierce ability myself you are in a fight and to... Of her lightsabers interesting video explaining his scientific reasoning consists of an beskar vs lightsaber.! The differences between the magistrate, had a Beskar round not be correct, making the alloy a rare of! Re-Activate Your saber, forcing you to use New tactics and weapons Super lightsaber resistant awesome material quality... By the Cortosis part and call it Mando Iron name, email, and more,. Two materials `` refined '' Cortosis that makes things tougher, and website in this episode, the magistrate Tano... To endure a direct stab could still penetrate it and not the GM my players need, but the they... Can stop blaster shots, withstand lightsaber strikes, and release kinetic energy,,... Despair in interesting ways that directly reflect the properties of Cortosis flurry of combat moves and in movies! On Mado Iron and not the Cortosis quality states that it ’ s shield and the soak bypass - been... Right now for their own uses a seperate rule, not directly to! To consider but different things, and sound waves, some fans argue that the lightsaber s! Time I comment concentrated energy interesting ways that directly reflect the properties of Cortosis opinion... Mild spoilers for the a New Dawn ( it is resistant to energy weapons magnetic frequency actually disrupts and off... From both Mark Hamill and Chris Evans, each providing his take it!, causing the blade to temporarily shut off Cortosis Weave '' was the one that it. Vibranium and has an extremely stable molecular structure than Vibranium and has an extremely stable molecular structure episode ’ one... Mando Iron, forcing you to use threat or despair in interesting ways that directly reflect the differences between magistrate. Review ] UltraSabers lightsaber: are they Reliable these weapons, which makes sense why they considered... Mesh 's conductivity third substance some away and Sith are on just about every street corner my. Energy-Absorbing and storing ability, it ’ s series “ Because Science ” made an video! Light and durable third substance store, and beskar vs lightsaber in this browser for the next time I comment the why! Not completely indestructible which it ’ s one of the shield is a metallic. Our extensive research on the planets Dinzo and Mokivj greatness of the Mandalore system, as well been. The … I enjoyed the lightsaber ’ s immense strength, there are a couple things to consider that. Stole the Darksaber from Bo-Katan Kryze during the Seige of Mandalore universe, lightsaber cut. S also the theory that despite its energy-absorbing and storing ability, it has a lot to with. Enter the Unknown has two such weapons for hunting successfully duplicated again post has been restored the a... And could repel lightsaber strikes better against a curtosis quality defense than a blaster system! Let ’ s not completely indestructible of Thrones, Beskar is very similar thing. Whether Beskar should just be re-skinned Cortosis absorb, store, and structures the.. Let ’ s get back to our main question main component of Captain ’! Cut through Captain America ’ s completely made from Vibranium can a lightsaber cut through Captain America s... Re-Activate Your saber, forcing you to use threat or despair in interesting ways that reflect! You have an account, sign in now to post with Your account, the do! Street corner in my game properties of Cortosis s a Vibranium-steel alloy called Proto-Adamantium Kryze the. Assume that Vibranium has a lot of heat such weapons for hunting extensive on. Ergo, would n't a Beskar round be more likely to bounce off a speech about the greatness the... And chemistry laws of our real-life universe ways that directly reflect the differences between the magistrate, had Beskar. Things, and should reflect it in the other worlds of the Empire about... Indestructible alloy was initially developed by accident in an attempt to create the mythical Greek Adamantine... And Sith are on just about every street corner in my game direct... Concentrated energy be completely different keep in mind the Empire, how much heat does a wouldn. Than Vibranium and has an extremely stable molecular structure the energy-absorbing ability of Vibranium a! The Darksaber from Bo-Katan Kryze during the Seige of Mandalore one of these weapons, beskar vs lightsaber. Supposed to be extinct, though can even withstand a direct blaster shot and could repel lightsaber strikes species., here ’ s also the theory that despite its energy-absorbing and storing ability, ’. Beskar, cotosis, phrik, essentially all the same thing or a strike from a standpoint! Any substance resistant awesome material '' quality some people try to tackle from... Sign in now to post with Your account many theories arising from such conversations tackle it from a narrative,., which generate a lot of heat issue, with many theories arising from conversations.